Cygnet: The Sorceress and the Cygnet (Apr 2007)

amazon / b&n


Corleu, a young Wayfolk man, is trapped into a search for the heart of the Cygnet by one of the legendary powers of his world in order to free his love from being eternally trapped. He finds help from the sorceress Nyx, daughter of the ruling family of Ro House, though he is not allowed to tell her what he seeks, and the two of them release the powers of legend. But another daughter of Ro House is destined to protect the Cygnet, even from her own. Each riddle surrounding the Cygnet is answered with yet another riddle that only another legend can answer until Corleu, followed by a power hungry sorceress, and legendary powers that have come to life, finally reaches the hiding place of the Cygnet itself where discovers his past and frees his future.

Impression: While not one of my favorite McKillip reads, I found The Sorceress and the Cygnet enjoyable -- not fantastic enjoyable, but okay enjoyable. The title and the book don't actually quite fit together, though Nyx is a big part of the story, she is not the important part of the story. However, I also understand why it the title is what it is, I just feel it misleads the prospective reader. In any case, the story itself in interesting, though the style lacks the lyrical quality I have appreciated in a number of her past books. I'm honestly not sure why I didn’t feel more drawn into the book than I was -- it's not a bad read, just an okay one. The world is intriguing and the writing solid. The weak link, I think, was the characters. Corleu does have a compelling reason for his actions which are the foundation for the plot, but I didn't feel there was as much depth to these characters as there could have been. The one exception was Meguet. It really seemed as if the story should be about her, but not in the round about way it happened. The ties of discovery that seemed to link Corleu and Meguet were not as strongly written as they could have been.

So, an okay read, but not a particularly impressive one. It falls short of McKillip's usual care in her writing. I can see it being more interesting to pre-y.a. readers, actually. When I finish the next book, I may just pass it along to my 12 year old and see if she likes it. ;)



domy

~*~

« Solstice Wood :: Proven Guilty »

about
recent reads
past reads
MoveableType

~*~

reads by category
mythopoeic challenge '08
2003 Reads (22)
2004 reads (18)
2005 Reads (14)
2006 Reads (7)
2007 Reads (12)
2008 Reads
Lilley Press
authors: Butcher
authors: Klasky
authors: Lackey
authors: Lia Block
authors: McKillip
authors: Roberson
authors: Zimmer Bradley
best reads: fantasy
best reads: fiction
best reads: on writing
best reads: science fiction
best reads: y.a./children
bookcrossing.com
chick lit
classics
classics (sff)
classics (y.a./children)
fantasy
fantasy (adult)
fantasy (literary)
on autism
on reading
on writing
other fiction
paranormal romance
romance
science fiction
series: Chronicles of Amber
series: Dresden Files
y.a./children's lit
young adult

"Rhysa and the Dragon" © 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005 by Amanda Penrose and created exclusively for Denyse "domynoe" Loeb; All Rights Reserved. Not be duplicated, copied, uploaded to another server, linked to, or used for any other purpose other than viewing while visiting the domynoes network and affiliated domains. In other words, it was made for me, I paid for it, it is mine, hands (and mice) off. This website has been optimized for 800x600 and 1024x768 monitor resolutions.

Graphics, Site Design, Content & Writings © 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005 by Denyse "Domynoe" Loeb unless otherwise noted. Except where noted, all graphics and content created/authored by Denyse "domynoe" Loeb. Gifts pages copyrighted by their respective creators and were created exclusively for Domynoe. All rights reserved. Graphics, design, and content writings may not be duplicated, copied, uploaded to another server, or used for any other purpose other than viewing while visiting the domynoes network and all affiliated sites including domynoes.com, domynoes.net, alden.nu, dreamininink.com and dragyncat.com. While linking to individual pages are permitted, links must NOT hide the original URL or domain, may not be framed off the network, or interfere with navigation of the original domain. Graphics and other files may not be linked to outside the pages on which they appear within the network and associated domains. For more information, please visit one or more of the following: what is copyright | 10 myths about copyrights | u.s. copyright faq | r.i.g.h.t.s. | no electronic theft. Special thanks to M. J. Young for help with this copyright notice.